I’ve recently noticed a diet that is trending – the carnivore diet – not just among people in general, but also among people with IBS. Being a dietitian makes me very interested in all diets, but I must say this one makes me very curious. From my educational background this diet seems to be completely counterproductive, as it goes against all dietary guidelines out there. So why is it becoming a thing anyway?
It's because some people who follow the carnivore diet report feeling much better after switching. They feel more energetic and lighter than before. They report that their IBS symptoms get better, even disappear in some cases. As a registered dietitian I must admit I am sceptical, so let’s dig in and see what is going on here.
Let’s first find out what this diet is. This diet is almost exactly as it sounds: it is all meat, fish and chicken. You are also allowed a little bit of cheese, heavy cream and eggs. Fat sources are lard and tallow, although some allow plant oils in the diet also. You can drink unsweetened coffee and tea and add spices that contain no carbs.
Basically, this diet is an extremely low carbohydrate diet, very high in protein, and high in fat. It is not possible to get all the nutrients your body needs from this diet, especially vitamin C, B vitamins, vitamin K and calcium, unless you include a variety of organ meats in your diet every day, like liver, kidney, and brain. For omega-3 fatty acids, it’s important to eat fatty fish, like salmon. Unless you drink coffee or tea, this diet contains hardly any antioxidants - these are highly beneficial for your health as they fight free radicals that damage your tissues. Animal foods contain no fiber that are needed to support the health of the gut microbiota.
To sum up, the carnivore diet is a highly restrictive eating plan that consists of 99% animal-based foods and carries with it a high risk of malnutrition. How is it possible then, to feel better with this diet?
There are no objective studies done, so I can’t say anything for sure, but I have a few theories why someone might feel better.
It’s important to note, however, that there is no guarantee that you will continue feeling better in the long term. I’m almost certain the feeling will go away quickly, as the gut microbiota changes will affect your health negatively. Scientists can’t even study this diet properly, as it is unethical to conduct a study on a diet that is known to be risky. Here are some reasons why it is highly risky to follow the carnivore diet, especially for longer than a few days.
I wouldn’t recommend anyone following the carnivore diet, but people who are pregnant, lactating, have heart disease, kidney disease and potentially diabetes should not try this diet. Some experts also include people with IBS in this group, as the digestive system needs fiber to function normally.
The carnivore diet (or any meat-heavy diet for that matter) is against the dietary recommendations of any given country in the world. But then we have Inuits who mostly eat fish and meat. They seem to do well on this diet. So why shouldn’t others do the same?
This is an excellent question! Here’s what I found.
The reason for why the Inuit have been thriving on a diet that is high in animal protein is a result of thousands of years of genetic adaptation. These genes help the Inuit utilize high-fat diets well, and these genes are not commonly found in Europeans for example.
However, it’s important to note that the traditional Inuit diet is not a carnivore diet, it also includes local plant foods, studies are estimating their diet is 8-50% carbohydrate. Also, the Inuit eat lots of marine mammals and fish, including their internal organs, which helps provide more of the nutrients the body needs.
It has been thought that heart disease doesn’t exist among the Inuit population, but this might not be the case. Another problem with this diet is also that it doesn’t promote bone health - the Inuit have been found to have very poor bone health and early onset osteoporosis.
If you have IBS, and are seeking a diet that minimizes symptoms, it shouldn't be the carnivore diet. It might not be the low FODMAP diet either. What you need is a balanced, highly individualized diet that takes into account much more than just your gut symptoms, such as your age, gender, background history, habits, skills and so on. This is what dietitians do – they look at your diet from all angles and recommend changes to support your gut health, your overall health and your wellbeing.
If you are considering trying out an extreme diet like the carnivore diet, it is a sign to talk to an IBS dietitian and get real solutions that bring you real results, without risking your long term health. Book a free gut health review with me to kickstart your journey to finding your very own, best possible IBS diet.
With love,
Anna-Kaisa
PS. If you haven’t yet, download my free “5 Easy Ways to Beat the Bloat” guide packed with actionable tips that you can start applying in your day to day life right away.
PPS. Let’s chat! There is a right IBS diet for you out there. Book your free gut health review now!
References:
When talking about irritable bowel syndrome and IBS symptoms (abdominal pain, bloating, diarrhea, constipation), the discussion is not complete without considering the gut-brain axis. Especially since IBS experts are now calling the syndrome a disorder of gut-brain interaction. It’s a fascinating subject that reminds you how everything in the body affects everything - in good and in bad. This applies also to managing IBS symptoms: it’s not enough to focus on one aspect of gut health, like your diet, but also sleep, circadian rhythms, exercise, stress, and even thoughts have to be assessed as all of these affect the gut-brain axis.
Often called the gut-brain-microbiota axis, the gut-brain axis is the communication channel between the gut and the brain, the two-directional phone line between the two.
Your gut and your brain are talking to each other all the time! The main office (the brain) wants to know what the branch office is doing (the gut) and give orders if need be. They relay information back and forth about gut processes, hunger, satiety, stress, and feelings, just to name a few.
Problems in this information exchange are linked to irritable bowel syndrome and other “functional” gut problems, immune function, sleep problems, mood disorders, neurodegenerative diseases, and even obesity.
It’s not simple. Many processes are involved:
To simplify, what you need to know is that
It’s not completely clear how this happens, but it seems stress plays a big role, as does the health of the gut microbiota. Your gut microbes are affected by your lifestyle and your diet, both in helpful and harmful ways. It is thought that dysbiosis of the gut microbiota (negative changes in your gut microbes) can cause problems in the gut-brain axis, but it is not clear whether dysbiosis happens first, or whether the disruption of the gut-brain axis causes the dysbiosis.
IBS can become triggered by a gut infection, which could support the idea that your gut microbe balance becomes disrupted first, but an infection also causes inflammation which the immune system controls. Gut infection is also a source of stress, and a sensitive brain may overreact to infection signals coming from the gut, starting a feedback loop that causes IBS. So, it’s not clear.
The brain then is responsible for assessing whether we are in danger or not, but your lifestyle and your diet can also affect your stress sensitivity, or how readily a stress response is triggered in the body. A typical Western diet and an irregular lifestyle with sleep deprivation could make you more sensitive to stress.
People who have had lots of stress in their lives, whether in childhood or in adulthood, become more sensitive to stress, and are at a higher risk for developing IBS. Studies show that over time their brains have adapted to stress in an unhelpful way, which explains this increased sensitivity, and probably also why not everyone with stress has IBS.
Additionally, people with IBS tend to have these similar structural brain changes and increased stress sensitivity also, and a history of highly stressful life periods. For example, I had a client whose gut symptoms began after a serious natural disaster hit her country. This all suggests that chronic stress wreaks havoc on the gut-brain axis and promotes chronic gut issues, like IBS.
What’s more, it’s relatively common that anxiety and depression happen together with IBS, both probably feeding the other. What came first, however, is not clear.
Everyone can benefit from taking good care of the gut-brain axis, but this is especially important for people with IBS and other functional digestive disorders. It seems that gut symptoms are like the tip of an iceberg – your gut-brain axis may have been disrupted for a while before gut symptoms surface!
How to nurture your gut-brain axis:
It’s a lot! But not impossible to do.
The first step is to map out honestly how you are doing in these different areas listed above.
The second step is to make a plan: what needs to change and in what order. Consider what might be easier to start with, or what might make the biggest impact.
But you don’t have to figure this out on your own. Nurturing a sturdy gut-brain axis and relieving IBS symptoms in the process is what I do. If you are not sure, let’s chat. You will have the opportunity to tell an expert about your situation, and I will go over your best next steps without you having to commit to a program. I want to make sure you and I are a good match before you invest anything in working together. Book you free consultation here.
I hope you enjoyed learning about the all-important gut-brain axis! If you are feeling overwhelmed by this, just remember that even small adjustments to diet, lifestyle, thought patterns and stress sensitivity can make a big difference. Check out all of my free resources (scroll down my home page) - they provide lots of tips to get going with.
Thank you for reading!
Love,
Anna-Kaisa
PS: Book your free 30-minute consultation here!
PPS: Feeling bloated? Get your copy of the free “5 Easy Ways to Beat the Bloat” guide here!
If you are wondering the answer to this question, you are not alone. There are millions of people out there experiencing gut symptoms and wondering if they should be worried about them.
The most common IBS symptoms are:
The way IBS is diagnosed, in order for your symptoms to “qualify” as IBS, abdominal pain must be present. It can be crampy, aching, and even quite severe. Often it is triggered or made worse by food, bowel movements and stress.
This abdominal pain is also often associated with a change in stool frequency or consistency. It typically gets better after having a bowel movement, and it would actually be concerning if it didn’t. Since abdominal pain in IBS is considered visceral pain, you’ll often feel pain in the midline of the body.
Bloating is a feeling of tightness and fullness of the abdomen, and your belly feels like it is visibly bigger, even though it may or may not be so. Distention is the term for your belly protruding more than usual with measurable increase in the abdominal circumference. People feel like they have a balloon in their belly, or that they are pregnant when they are not pregnant. Bloating and distention can cause discomfort and it may feel embarrassing.
Constipation is an infrequent bowel movement pattern, in which you have a bowel movement less than three times a week. Though it seems to me you can feel constipated even if you move your bowels daily. Constipation usually goes hand in hand with small, hard, pebble-like stools and they are hard to pass. You might feel like your bowels are not emptying fully.
Diarrhea is the opposite of constipation. It refers to loose, watery stools, more than three times per day. Diarrhea could also cause urgency - you can’t wait a minute longer to go to the bathroom or else an accident might happen.
These symptoms can be very debilitating. They might also change from day to day, one day having constipation and the next diarrhea. People experiencing IBS symptoms may feel like they need to watch closely what they eat, not stray too far from the toilet, and avoid going out to see friends, travel or eat out.
If you’ve been experiencing IBS symptoms for longer than a few weeks, or less if the symptoms are very difficult, I encourage you to go get them checked out. Then, even if your symptoms didn’t fulfill the IBS diagnostic criteria, you’d find out whether there’s something more serious going on, or whether there’s nothing to worry about. Either way, it’s better to be in the know than to be guessing!
If you have been diagnosed with IBS, but are not sure whether this is the right diagnosis, I would again encourage you to speak with your doctor. Ask how they diagnosed the disorder and voice your concerns. The end result (should be) that your doctor will either order more tests, or explain to you more thoroughly their thinking process, so that you can rest assured the right call has been made and that you can begin to apply the right therapies.
If you end up being diagnosed with IBS, or even if you’re not, I have what you need to improve your symptoms. Sign up to my IBSwise program, or if you’d like a more individualized approach, book a free 30-minute chat to discuss your next move.
Whatever you do, don’t be left alone with your symptoms! There is so much you can do to ease them.
Love,
Anna-Kaisa
Earlier this month National Geographic published an article headlined “Why women are more likely to have IBS”. I love that big publications such as National Geographic are paying attention to irritable bowel syndrome, as it is so common, and as there is so much misleading information out there. Big publications could help bust some of that misinformation.
The article aimed to explore why more women than men have IBS, and to discuss some of the treatment options. Since the comments below the original Instagram post, where I first spotted the article, seemed to point out some discrepancies, I thought I’d chime in and expand on some of the unclear points. Here are some of my thoughts:
Thanks for reading! I’m glad we are talking more about IBS publicly, but much more is needed! More publications should write about IBS in an easy-to-understand way. In the meantime you can ask me. I’m here to help!
Love,
Anna-Kaisa
PS: If you have questions about this, or any other gut health or stress topic, get in touch!
PPS: Did you download my free guide “Beat Stress and Boost Your Mood” yet?
Link to the original NatGeo article here.
Have you noticed that your gut functions differently depending on where you are in your cycle? That every time you are about to have your period, your gut gets messed up, or your already loose stools become worse?
You are not imagining it – female hormones do affect the gut, especially through pain sensitivity, how fast the gut contents move (motility), and indirectly through greater stress sensitivity (1-4). Female hormones could explain why women tend to have more IBS than men in general, and more IBS-C than men (1,2). In this article, I briefly go over what this means in terms of gut symptoms.
First, let’s briefly discuss the menstrual cycle. There are three phases:
Phase | Days | Estrogen and progesterone | Gut impact |
Menstruation phase | 1-7 | Both are low | Faster motility, higher risk of diarrhea, urgency Increased pain sensitivity |
Follicular phase | 8-14 (until ovulation) | Estrogen: Increases until peaks at ovulation Progesterone: low | Slower motility |
Luteal phase | 15-28 | Estrogen: high, drops quickly Progesterone: high | Slower motility |
Now, let’s dive into how female hormones can change how the gut functions.
Very simply put (I discuss this subject in more detail in my IBSwise course), estrogen affects the gut by lengthening gut transit time, which means that gut contents move slower through the intestines. When estrogen levels are high, gut moves slower, and when estrogen levels drop, gut motility increases. This is probably why women tend to be more prone to IBS-C, and have constipation especially during follicular and early luteal phases, and higher chance of diarrhea around menstruation. During pregnancy, estrogen levels are high, which could at least partially explain why constipation is so common in pregnant women, especially during the third trimester. (1,2)
On the other hand, progesterone’s effect on gut motility is not as clear, as it affects serotonin mechanisms also, but the overall effect seems to be similar to estrogen: higher levels are associated with slower gut movements (1).
It’s unclear how estrogen affects pain sensitivity, but it looks like changes in estrogen predispose to pain, such as a few days after ovulation when estrogen levels drop quickly (6). Pain sensitivity has also been found to be higher around menstruation when there is an increased number of serotonin receptors due to low estrogen, which leads to detecting pain and sensations more easily. Estrogen affects inflammatory pathways as well, which can lead to higher sensitivity – in IBS it has been noted that the number of a certain estrogen receptor is often high, which increases inflammation and therefore pain sensitivity (1,3,4).
Another mechanism that can increase gut symptoms in women is that women are naturally more reactive to stress than men. Female sex hormones have been connected to HPA-axis activity, and to a higher limbic system activity (1-3). This all lowers the threshold for a stress response to be triggered in the body, which leads to gut issues, especially in IBS.
What about women on birth control? According to Dr. Liao (5), birth control that allows for menstruation doesn’t protect from hormonal gut changes, but ones that skip menstruation could. Discuss with your doctor if you feel that at different phases of your cycle you experience difficult symptoms, whether it’s constipation during follicular and early luteal phase, or diarrhea and pain around menstruation phase. Still, even though female hormones seem to affect gut symptoms, data doesn’t support utilizing hormone therapies for women with IBS (3).
If your gut behaves differently during different phases of the menstrual cycle, it’s nice to know it is caused by your hormones. While I don’t recommend observing gut symptoms too closely, knowing when you are more likely to have diarrhea vs constipation could help you anticipate these changes.
Perhaps you can prepare a bit, also – if you are often constipated outside of menstruation, you could increase the amount of fiber you eat at that time of the month, whereas if you experience diarrhea during and close to menstruation, you could utilize soluble fiber from chia seeds, flaxseed and oatmeal. Additionally, focusing on anti-inflammatory foods during menstruation may be useful, like eating lots of colorful fruits and vegetables, and omega-3 rich foods, like walnuts, hempseed, and salmon, although these are important foods to eat every day.
So, female hormones and gut function are connected. Knowing how is useful, as you won’t be surprised by the changes, nor will there be a need to be worried. And you can make better food choices according to your cycle too.
Have a great summer!
Love,
Anna-Kaisa from AKWise
PS: Check out all the free giveaways on my home page!